I mentioned this in one of my posts a little while ago, but I recently started trying to watch Supernatural again. When I was a teenager I watched the show fairly regularly up until about season 6, when I finally threw up my hands and dropped out. The ideas were stale, the writing was bad, and the actors all seemed like they’d rather be somewhere else. So I moved on and forgot about the show and got my monster/mythology/hot dude jollies from other things.
But once every few years I come across it again. Somebody will mention it, or I’ll see a meme, or most recently it just started popping up on my recommended list on Netflix, and I go back to it, having forgotten the reasons why I left it in the first place.
This time I decided to start at season 8. I’d heard from people that the Leviathan season was one of the worst, and if I was going to go back I should start after that. So I did, and because I don’t have a lot going on in my life right now, I almost made it all the way through the season before dropping off again. I went through about twenty episodes before the sexist, homophobic, bro-doucheyness of the show finally pushed me away (and left me wondering what the writers room of that show must look like. I’m picturing a bunch of variations of the comic book guy from the Simpsons and a few teenage gamers).
And after dropping off this time I started asking myself, why do I keep coming back to this show? I think it’s because it should be something that I love. Two hot dudes driving across small town America and hunting monsters from folklore? That is so my god damn wheelhouse. And when it started out it was actually pretty good! Wasn’t it? I remember the beginning of the series being gritty and scrappy, gumshoe mysteries where the two brothers were always in over their heads, figuring it out as they went along. They came up with clever ideas to get ahead of creatures that were stronger and faster than them. Now it runs the same formula every time. They fight a thing that’s unstoppable, it throws them across the room, they get up, it throws them again, they stab it with something (usually after saying something, the jist of which is “you’re probably gay!”), it dies. I think I know why too. This show suffers from the same problem as a lot of other shows, especially those with super powered enemies: control of the escalation of threat.
In order to keep things feeling fresh, to keep people engaged, the writers feel like they needed to keep increasing the power of the enemies that the two brothers face. This isn’t just a run of the mill monster, they’ve killed those before, this is a demon. Really scary stuff. Oh, they’ve got pretty good at killing demons, well…this is the Mother of Demons! Hmmm…still not good enough? This is The Devil! Old Gods. More Old Gods. Tons of Old Gods! Zeus? But the problem with escalating the threat like this is that eventually you end up writing yourself into a corner. You get to a point where it doesn’t make sense that your protagonists can win anymore. One way to solve this is by coming up with clever, out-smarty ways that your heroes can prevail. They plan ahead and lay an ambush, or they have some elaborate twisty plot to get on top.The problem is that in order to write smart, interesting solutions to problems you have to be, you know, smart. And not only do you have to be smart, you have to put in the time. The easier road, and the one that most shows like this take, is to not play fair with the audience. They have demons that can make people throw up their own blood until they die by waving their hands, but when they fight Dean and Sam they just…toss them about. Angels are super fast, and super duper strong, they can teleport and scrub out demons with a touch, but when one of them full on punches the Winchesters in the face, instead of their head exploding, they just get a fetching bruise or slightly cut lip. Powerful enemies seem to consistently forget how powerful they’re supposed to be. This has the consequence of completely undermining any of the tension, instead of ratcheting it up. Because there’s no consistency, because nothing really means anything (this person can make you explode by looking at you! Well, not you, you’re a main character. But other people. They can do it to other people sometimes), it all just feels kinda of…meh.
Anyways, I’m not going to spend anymore time on this show. It’s not really worth it. It’s a mediocre show, aimed at the lowest common denominator, topped off with a heavy dose of casual, bro-y homophobia and sexism (seriously, in one episode of this season Dean says, “You abandoned me for a girl, Sam? A girl!”, one of the hunters is a young woman with a bit of an edge and she’s described as “mouthy”. Can you guys please get one full-grown ass woman on your writing team? And if there is one already I…well, I don’t really know how to help you). Do yourself a big favour and give this one a miss. Or, you know, don’t. I’m not your mom.
Very Biased Reviewer